HELP! How fast does Oriental Trading ship?

I waited too long to order the pinata filling stuff, and i was wondering if any of you know if OTC has quick shipping (quicker than it tells you to expect). I have three items (toy assortment, happy face rings, lizard and snakes) and need them by Sun Oct 8. I don't really want to pay for overnight shipping! even when i click on the 3-5 day shipping option, it says to expect shipping by oct 9.

or is there another cheap favor place that would get me similiar stuff by next weekend?

HELP!

thanks for any help. :-)

Anne + DD 10-03

I'm in NC. Once my stuff leaves their warehouse, it never takes more than 3 days to get to me. But, if it takes them more than a day to get the shipment out, it would be too risky for me.

I noticed that walmart and target had a bunch of halloween toys (for trick or treating) that would work in a pinata, but most are halloween themed.

Ours came really fast to the Seattle area. We used regular shipping (we had tons of time) and it only took about 3 days.