I'm in the pro-PP camp too! I've used this chair for 4 years and still really like it. Granted, my kids *are* tall, but we never had a problem with the tray being too high.

When I take it outside and really clean it and hose it off, it still looks brand new!

(And I bought mine because it coordinated with my decor also! :) I got the baby blue with yellow gingham--it's very bright and cheery.)