Size 4
Size 5
Other (smaller/larger/or already potty trained - wow!)
Hannah has always been my little peanut. When she was two, I think that she was in size 3's. And when she turned 3 went into 4's.
Mama to "The Fantastic Four":
DS 02
DD 06
DS 09
DD 12
I'm thinking this diaper size range is crazy! My size 3 wearing ds is 25lbs and 33", same stats as some kiddos that are wearing a 5. He is still comfy in 3's, they don't leak and you get more in the pack for the same $.
Beth
DD is in size 4s, she is almost 20 mos. I just got some size 5s, because getting her into the 4s was too much effort. The size range on the diapers are ridiculous. She was in 4s for almost a year though.
DD was in size 4 Cruisers forever. We recently switched to 5s because the 4s seemed a little short. She's on the tall and thin side.
DD January 2008
DS September 2011
My older son wore size 4 until he PT'ed a little past 2-1/2.
My younger son is 21 months old and in size 4. He's been in size 4 forever it seems and I wasn't planning on moving him out anytime soon. After reading this thread, though, I am thinking about trying size 5. I was thinking just to leave him in size 4 like his bro, but he's heftier (27lbs, no idea how tall) and 5 might be better. 4 does leave a few marks.
DS is in size 5 Kirkland diapers. I have tried the 4s since I know it's a better deal but they seem to small for him.
at 2 DD wore a size 6. At 2.5 DD is now PT.
Heather
DS 2004
DD 2007
I voted other b/c 2.5 yr old ds has been in underwear for 2 weeks now! WooooHoooooo!!
He's small - 28lbs - and he had been wearing sz 4 Huggies Supreme as well as overnights. Now his "crib undies" (aka pull-ups, ssshhh) are 2t Seventh Generation. He's wearing them for nighttime only and it's working great b/c they are much more like cloth and don't look anything like prior diapers. Not that you asked, but I recommend them if you need something transitional.
For a few weeks I had the new baby and ds1 in Huggies Pure & Natural. The designs on those are very light and more than once I put the size 4 dipe on the size 2 babe, accidentally. Worked surprisingly fine. Not so much the other way around!
Big Brother 5/07
Little Brother 9/09