Didn't think I'd ever be posting one of these questions, but here goes!

DD is invited to a party for a boy in her class (the whole class-8 kids-were invited). The problem lies in that the party is also for an older sibling that we don't know. It's a 1st grader and a 4th grader (according to DD).

I bought a Target gift card for the boy in her class....and then realized that I should probably also get the same thing for the other boy....right? DD doesn't know the older boy as far as I know, so this feels awkward, but what is the right thing to do?