I haven't used either one, but thought I would throw in my 2 cents. We used a pack-n-play with both DC, currently using for my 3 month old. We put it close enough to the bed, that I could rock/jiggle it to put the baby back to sleep. That doesn't work any more though, as DD needs to be picked up and swayed. I don't think it is that important to literally have the baby right next to the bed in regards to breastfeeding. my DC always need new diapers before or during a feeding, so I was always getting up anyway. Both DC had reflux too, so no laying down and feeding. I have to keep DD angled upright, using My Brest Friend with a pillow underneath. The pack-n-play does take up a lot of room, but since it won't be there for too long, I don't really mind. Plan on transitioning DD to her crib in the next month or so. I would think either one of your choices will work fine. Maybe think about which you will get more use out of.