I bought one at Costco years ago and the same thing happened. The color side was still soft but the white side was matted and rough so I passed that one to DH and bought myself a new one. The new one is a few years old and holding up much better than my first one. It's still soft and snuggly. Not sure if they changed them? FWIW my old one was a light green and this one is a dark blue.
Mom to:
1 BLUE (03) and 2 PINK (05 & 07)
^i^ 10.01 & 12.03
Pardon my typos...blasted Auto-correct!!
We are up to seven now and have gifted that many if not more. They are everyone's favorite! They now have queen and king sized ones that are only the colored part (that makes sense if you have seen them) on both sides without any of the white fluffy stuff. I dare say we like those better...the white "sheep" part seems to trap stray strings and such but these new ones don't.