Protect A Bub vs Rayshade

[klass2]

Have any of you guys had the opportunity to try both out?

I ask b/c I purchased a single Rayshade at Babies R Us last fall to go onto my E3. I bought the Rayshade b/c it was cheaper and I didn't have to order it.

But I was disappointed with the flimsyness of it. When it was on and the wind blew, it just flopped all over the place, not matter how tight I had it stretched on.

I've since sold my E3, but have a Valco Twin and was wondering if I should get the Double Rayshade again or try the Protect A Bub.

Is the Protect A Bub more sturdy? Will it not flop in the wind as much?

Or should I try one of the sunshade/mosquito netting things?

TIA
katie

[NewMom04]

I also have the E3 with the Rayshade and it does flop once in a while. Funny you ask bc just earlier today I was just trying to figure out if my sister's Protect a Bub was better. From a brief comparison, IMO the PAB has a more breathable or mesh type material, so it might let wind pass through and be less floppy. I actually liked the material better than the Rayshade. The shape seems better -enveloped around the Joovy caboose's canopy more if that makes any sense. Today was breezy, but not windy enough to see if it's floppy.
HTH some.

Annie