Classica I versus Classica II

[notrub9]

I know this has come up many times before, but I figured I'd post a new thread dedicated to this topic because the other ones seem to jump in with other brands.

I am sold on a Colgate, and trying to decide between the Classica I and II. I know the Classica I is firmer, and highly rated, so I am wondering about the Classica II. Any feedback on which you would choose?

[nonamestill]

I'm also curious about this, especially since the new Baby Bargains book will be coming out soon (or has it come out already?). I'm wondering if it's still the Classica I that is the most highly-rated among the foam mattresses in the new book. If anyone has this info, please share. Thank you!

[notrub9]

I'm also curious about this, especially since the new Baby Bargains book will be coming out soon (or has it come out already?). I'm wondering if it's still the Classica I that is the most highly-rated among the foam mattresses in the new book. If anyone has this info, please share. Thank you!


I do have the new edition of BB and it is still the Classica I.

[nonamestill]

I do have the new edition of BB and it is still the Classica I.

Thanks! If you don't mind, what are the runners-up for the foam mattress category?

[notrub9]

The runner-up is Moonlight Slumber's Starlight Support.

[Lila]

Anyone considering the Colgate Visco-Classica?