help me pick a sporty mary jane shoe?

[skohng]

hi all,

I need something super comfortable. Something in the office on casual days would be nice, but not the first priority. just something COMFY! some options I'm eyeing:

Land's end Toe Strap MJ Trekker:
http://www.landsend.com/pp/ToeStrapMaryJaneTrekkerShoes~191689_253.html?bcc=y&action=order_more&sku_0=::GUG&CM_MERCH=IDX_00002__0000000181

Land's End Z-Strap Terrain:
http://www.landsend.com/pp/ZstrapTerrainJaneShoes~186776_253.html?bcc=y&action=order_more&sku_0=::HGE&CM_MERCH=IDX_00002__0000000181&origin=index


Privo Maltese:
http://www.amazon.com/privo-by-Clarks-Womens-Maltese/dp/B0015VIXKM/ref=pd_sbs_shoe_4

Privo Luca:
http://www.amazon.com/privo-by-Clarks-LUCA-Womens/dp/B001FORDKU/ref=dp_also-recommended_2?ie=UTF8&n=672123011&s=shoes

Palladium Kassel:
http://www.amazon.com/Palladium-Womens-Kassel-White-Perforated/dp/B000Y03CKG/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=shoes&qid=1247151863&sr=1-1

J-41 Aquarius:
http://www.garnethill.com/jump.jsp?itemType=PRODUCT&RS=1&itemID=15549&fromNewSearch=true&mercadoResultId=3
I'm open to suggestions too! I appreciate any input. Thanks!

[boolady]

I can't see the photo of the J-41's, which I tend to like, but I like the first Lands End one and the second Privo one.

[Andi98989]

Out of the ones you listed, I like these the best:

Land's End Z-Strap Terrain
Privo Luca

These may not be quite sporty enough, but what about the Plaza Flaunt, Plaza Bandeau or Spire Emme from Merrell? Their Cruz MJ might be a good option, too.

I've worn Merrell's for years and love them! The arch support is great and they're super comfortable. They last quite a long time, too.

[skohng]

thanks for the merrell recs! I haven't even thought about that.

[KathyN115]

Out of the ones you posted, I like the second Privo one as well. I tried on similar Lands End shoes and didn't find them comfortable at all.

I have and love these (but in a pewter color):

http://www.jcpenney.com/jcp/X6.aspx?DeptID=68549&CatID=68549&Grptyp=PRD&ItemId=16a5003&cm_mmc=ShoppingFeed-_-Google-_-Juniors-_-Nike%20Mary%20Jane%20Women%20s%20Shoe%20%20JCPenne y

So so comfortable! And they stay on my hard-to-fit foot, while most closed-back shoes flap right off. They run TTS in case you are interested.

I also have these, not quite as comfy but still very good:

http://www.shoes.com/Shopping/ProductDetails.aspx?p=EC1104484

These are dressy enough to wear to work IMO. They would even work with a skirt, because they don't look too much like sneakers (but they feel like them!). They are TTS also.

HTH! Kathy

[skohng]

ooh thanks for these recs! that nike one is a great deal!!

i never know how to size in these. i wear 7 in most flats and dress shoes, sometimes 7.5. But I wear a size 8 in running shoes. Is it best to wear these typs of shoes like ballet flats, or with more toe room like running shoes?


Out of the ones you posted, I like the second Privo one as well. I tried on similar Lands End shoes and didn't find them comfortable at all.

I have and love these (but in a pewter color):

http://www.jcpenney.com/jcp/X6.aspx?DeptID=68549&CatID=68549&Grptyp=PRD&ItemId=16a5003&cm_mmc=ShoppingFeed-_-Google-_-Juniors-_-Nike%20Mary%20Jane%20Women%20s%20Shoe%20%20JCPenne y

So so comfortable! And they stay on my hard-to-fit foot, while most closed-back shoes flap right off. They run TTS in case you are interested.

I also have these, not quite as comfy but still very good:

http://www.shoes.com/Shopping/ProductDetails.aspx?p=EC1104484

These are dressy enough to wear to work IMO. They would even work with a skirt, because they don't look too much like sneakers (but they feel like them!). They are TTS also.

HTH! Kathy

[KathyN115]

I am usually an 8.5 in most shoes, sometimes an 8. In sneakers I would probably be a 9, but its been a long time. The 8.5 fit me perfectly, the 8 was too tight. I would probably get your regular size, because you don't want them to be falling off, and I doubt you will be wearing big socks with them!;)

[fivi2]

I have a pair of J-41 Dune (closed toe sandals, not a mary jane) that I love. Very comfy and I can wear with anything. I did pick the larger of the two sizes I am between and had to break in some of the straps, but I really like the shoes!

eta: http://www.zappos.com/n/p/p/7376689/c/20.html

I have the black.

[boolady]

I have a pair of J-41 Dune (closed toe sandals, not a mary jane) that I love. Very comfy and I can wear with anything. I did pick the larger of the two sizes I am between and had to break in some of the straps, but I really like the shoes!

eta: http://www.zappos.com/n/p/p/7376689/c/20.html

I have the black.

Those are really cute.

[JTsMom]

For comfort, I think it's hard to beat Privos. Have you seen the Acacia's?

http://www.amazon.com/Privo-Womens-Acacia-Flat-Stone/dp/B000WI0H30/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&s=shoes&qid=1247166916&sr=1-3

I have these:
http://www.amazon.com/Privo-Womens-Mesa-Flat-Aloe/dp/B000WI02D0/ref=sr_1_23?ie=UTF8&s=shoes&qid=1247167046&sr=1-23

They aren't a MJ, but they I loooove them. :) I get so many compliments on them, and they go with almost anything.

[CiderLogan]

I LOVE Privos - you really can't go wrong with them in terms of comfort, and I think the styles are really cute! I also love Merrells. I, too, have tried on the Lands' End ones that have that Privo-ish look, but I also found them to be uncomfortable (stiff and inflexible). Do you have a Clarks store near you?

[sadie427]

I love Ahnu brand, model Benecia, I have them in three colors and that's my go-to casual shoe. Unlike other similar shoes I've tried, your feet don't get sweaty if you wear them w/out socks.

I have two styles of Merrell MJ's too--those are dressy enough for work.