dumb question of the day - pls explain baked oatmeal

[lmh2402]

i've seen the threads on recipes for baked oatmeal, but i've never had it and i would love to know a little more about its consistency and how it is eaten?... is it solid/formed? or mushy? is it appropriate for a 13 months old? is it something you have to eat the day you make it? or does it keep?

thanks

[PAfirsttimemom]

I'm so glad you posted this. I've wondered about baked oatmeal, too, after reading a post on here. I'm not even clear on whether it's supposed to be a breakfast type food or more of a sweet treat. Or is it both? Please enlighten!

[kristenk]

Last week, I finally made my first successful batch of baked oatmeal. I had tried before, but my ratio of liquid/oatmeal must have been off and it just wasn't pleasant. Last week's batch, however, was fabulous.

DH and I eat it for breakfast or as a snack. DD likes to have it after school. Last week's batch had blueberries in it and this week's batch was a combo of raspberries and blueberries. I make a half batch at a time in a 9" square pyrex. My last two batches have been close to a cake consistency. I like to microwave servings for about 15-30 seconds to warm them up.

The first batch I made long, long ago was more mushy. That doesn't work for our family, I guess. No one was all that into it.

I'm not positive on refrigeration. I kept last week's batch in the fridge, but forgot to stick this week's batch in so it stayed on the counter. I think that refrigeration might be a function of whether you go with a custardy or cake-like version.

[Sillygirl]

Mine have come out moister than cake, with a coarser crumb. I'm down to two eggs and a cup of milk, trying to get a slightly drier texture. What I love about it is that I make a 9x13 pan, stick it in the fridge, and that's breakfast taken care of for the whole week. DH gets up, microwaves two squares, and pours OJ while I'm in the shower. The boys love it and so far I've changed flavors every week and they don't get bored.

It's got fiber, protein from the milk and eggs, good fats from the egg yolks, and fruit. When I have some for breakfast it's filling enough to keep me going until lunch. For a quick convenient breakfast that my DH is willing to prepare, it is by far the healthiest option I've found. I wish I had tried it two years ago!

[Melaine]

Mine is thick, dense, and cuttable. We call it cake, it is crumbly and kind of messy but we love it. I keep it in a brownie pan with a lid in the fridge and we eat it all week. We have it about 90% of our mornings for breakfast. The girls love it. I've gone out of town and taken a pan and it is great to have breakfast ready to go. I love carbs myself, so having any kind of bread/cake type item that is so healthy and flour-free is a breakfast dream come true.:)

[Green_Tea]

I tried making a batch last week (after the big thread on here) and it turned out with a pasty, heavy consistency. The kids took one bite and refused to eat more. Even DH didn't like it - and the man will eat nearly anything. I ended up throwing away nearly an entire batch, which I was bummed about because it seemed like a waste of a lot of ingredients.

I'd like to try again, but would love VERY specific instructions about what kind of oatmeal (quick vs. old fashion), exactly how much milk, what kind of yogurt (I used Greek style, so that might have contributed to my problems), etc. My kids are not big on fruit mix-ins and we have nut allergies, so if anyone has ideas for other additions (cinnamon/sugar? chocolate chips?) I'd love to hear them.

[sunshine873]

Thank you for posting this question!

I'm always looking for a healthy snack that doesn't have to be kept cold. Especially now as we're coming into summer. So, it sounds like some refrigerate & some don't. Right? Would it be OK to take a few pieces, put into a baggie in the diaper bag and be out & about all day?

[icunurse]

I've only made 2 batches now, but both came out pretty much the same - if cut out hot from the oven, it is not able or barely able to hold all of its shape. When being cut from the fridge, it holds its shape fine and looks like a piece of cake. But it is very moist and thick, so not cake-like in consistency in that way. Reheated, it holds its shape.

I have been taking it as a 5pm snack for work - very filling and keeps me from rushing home after a 12-hour shift and eating everything in sight.

[m448]

Mine comes out like a very moist oat cake. I cut off hunks, nuke it for 45 seconds and then drizzle about 1/4-/1/2 cup of milk over each one. Totally tastes like dessert. My husband likes it without the extra milk.

[egoldber]

if cut out hot from the oven, it is not able or barely able to hold all of its shape. When being cut from the fridge, it holds its shape fine and looks like a piece of cake. But it is very moist and thick, so not cake-like in consistency in that way. Reheated, it holds its shape.

This is what mine is like. I have found that the amount of initial moisture doesn't matter, but the amount of moisture added at the end just before baking does. The basic recipe calls for 4 eggs and 1-2 cups milk. I used 2 eggs and 1 cup milk. If you add a lot of fruit (especially fresh or frozen) it will also make it very moist. I don't like it very sweet, so I only add about 1/3 cup sugar. So it is highly adjustable and you can tweak it to how you like it.

After mine cools, I cut it into chunks and freeze half and put half in the refrigerator. I eat a square at work each day around 9 as my "second breakfast". :)

[g-mama]

I've made this twice and sadly, nobody like it but me. :( And I definitely do NOT need to eat a 9x13 pan of anything all by myself!

[egoldber]

I'm generally the only one who eats it in our house too. DH likes it OK but is not a big fan. My younger DD likes it, but DH doesn't like to feed it to her for whatever reason. This is why I freeze half. It takes me about a week to eat half the pan, then I usually eat something else for a week and then eat the other half over the course of a week. So I really only make it about once a month.

[Ceepa]

I made it and there were no takers. I ate some of it but wasn't really excited to do so. :)

I like the idea of it, though.

[Momof3Labs]

Mine comes out very moist - thicker than instant oatmeal, and definitely not cake-like. I use frozen fruit (a lot of it, the more the better lol) which increases the moisture content a lot, and contributes to the looser texture. I'm pretty much the only one who eats it. DS2 did at one time but then stopped. In a few months, I'll probably start making it again and see if DDs will eat it; right now, they'll eat pretty much anything that lands on their tray!

I make a 9x13 pan and refrigerate it, eating it throughout the week for breakfast.

[kristenk]

I'd like to try again, but would love VERY specific instructions about what kind of oatmeal (quick vs. old fashion), exactly how much milk, what kind of yogurt (I used Greek style, so that might have contributed to my problems), etc. My kids are not big on fruit mix-ins and we have nut allergies, so if anyone has ideas for other additions (cinnamon/sugar? chocolate chips?) I'd love to hear them.

I'll take a shot at this, but I'm a newbie at baked oatmeal (aka oatmeal cake in our house).

I make a half batch in an 8" square pyrex glass pan.

2.5 cups of old fashioned oats
1 cup of stonyfield low-fat organic yogurt (vanilla b/c that's what we have)
1 cup of warm water

I mix the above together the night before and leave it in the fridge b/c I just feel weird leaving it out on the counter overnight.

The next day, I add:
2 eggs
1/2 cup of sugar or brown sugar (I've done both)
1/2 cup of applesauce (in place of oil)
1.5 tsp. cinnamon
1.5 tsp. baking powder
1 tsp. vanilla

After the above is mixed with the oatmeal mixture, I add:
1 cup of milk
1 cup of frozen berries

I bake the whole thing for about 1 hour b/c I prefer a cakey consistency.

If I don't have time to mix the oatmeal the night before, I think that I'd adjust the recipe by not adding quite as much milk (maybe 1/2 - 3/4 cup instead of a full cup)

I'm not much help for other mix-ins. We're happily stuck on a blueberry/raspberry combo. I've been very tempted to make a raspberry/chocolate chip combo, though!

Have you tried to use very small pieces of fruit? I used teeny wild blueberries in ours and DD didn't have a problem.

[boolady]

I just made this tonight, to refrigerate for the week. When it was in the oven, I realized that I had totally forgotten to add any milk, so I thought it was going to be terrible. Not so. I just tasted a small piece after I put DD to bed. Yum. I guess because I threw in a lot of frozen berries, they added enough moisture to make up the difference, because it's definitely on the moist side, at least now, about 3 hours after coming out of the oven. I had also used 2 c. yogurt before I realized that I only had 4 cups of oatmeal, not 5. The fact that the recipe seems flexibe makes it all the better.

[Green_Tea]

I'll take a shot at this, but I'm a newbie at baked oatmeal (aka oatmeal cake in our house).

I make a half batch in an 8" square pyrex glass pan.

2.5 cups of old fashioned oats
1 cup of stonyfield low-fat organic yogurt (vanilla b/c that's what we have)
1 cup of warm water

I mix the above together the night before and leave it in the fridge b/c I just feel weird leaving it out on the counter overnight.

The next day, I add:
2 eggs
1/2 cup of sugar or brown sugar (I've done both)
1/2 cup of applesauce (in place of oil)
1.5 tsp. cinnamon
1.5 tsp. baking powder
1 tsp. vanilla

After the above is mixed with the oatmeal mixture, I add:
1 cup of milk
1 cup of frozen berries

I bake the whole thing for about 1 hour b/c I prefer a cakey consistency.

If I don't have time to mix the oatmeal the night before, I think that I'd adjust the recipe by not adding quite as much milk (maybe 1/2 - 3/4 cup instead of a full cup)

I'm not much help for other mix-ins. We're happily stuck on a blueberry/raspberry combo. I've been very tempted to make a raspberry/chocolate chip combo, though!

Have you tried to use very small pieces of fruit? I used teeny wild blueberries in ours and DD didn't have a problem.

THANK YOU!!! I will try again next week. You're the best!!

[graciebellesmomma]

What temperature do you bake it at?

Thanks!

[kristenk]

What temperature do you bake it at?

Thanks!

I bake it at 350.