Which shoes with this dress? Update in #23

[katydid1971]

OK since none of you would go shopping with me today I bought 3 pairs of shoes to go with my dress and I would love to hear your opinion. If you don't like any of them please suggest another options :) FYI I will wear silver jewelry with it.
Thanks
My Dress http://shop.nordstrom.com/s/lauren-by-ralph-lauren-elsie-shirred-jersey-dress/3145007?origin=keywordsearch&resultback=456
Pair #1 (In red) http://www.dsw.com/shoe/liz+claiborne+minnie+patent+slingback?prodId=20196 8&productRef=SEARCH
Pair #2 (also red) http://www.dsw.com/shoe/moda+spana+candie+patent+pump?prodId=194165&productRef=SEARCH
Pair #3 http://www.dsw.com/shoe/jones+new+york+jelous+metallic+sandal?prodId=dsw12 prod3090051&category=dsw12cat750002

[ciw]

I like both of the red pairs.

[bubbaray]

Pair #2, definitely.

[nupe]

I like #3, given silver jewelry plan and my personal fear of red shoes.

[mimi2008]

I like #2.

[WatchingThemGrow]

I would pick the red pair that's most comfortable. #1 looks more comfy.

[SnuggleBuggles]

I would pick the red pair that's most comfortable. #1 looks more comfy.

:yeahthat: I don't think you can go wrong with any of the pairs though.

Beth

[infomama]

I like both reds but #1 more. Not diggin' the heel on #2 as much for some reason.

[KLD313]

I like number 1, I like the color better.

[weech]

I like #2 - those heels are FIERCE! :heartbeat:

[ohsara430]

#1, I have them in black and they are very comfy. Any of them would be good though :)

[elbenn]

All of them would look great with that dress. #1 seems the most comfy and I love the color, so that is probably the one I would go with. My favorite shoe of all of them is #3 though. But I think the red would stand out a little more. Beautiful dress!

[mackmama]

love the dress!! i'd go with a red pair - i think i actually like #1 better.

[cuca_]

Another vote for #2!

[hellokitty]

#1, but I think that they all look fine.

[ilfaith]

Another vote for #2. Love red shoes.

[Melaine]

I vote for 1 but I really like all three options.

[crl]

All good choices, if equally comfortable, I vote number 2.

Catherine

[zag95]

I'd come down from Portland to shop with you!!!!

I'd do #2 as my top choice, followed by #1!!!! Love the red!

[DrSally]

#2 in red. Man, I wish I could wear high heels. They will really make the outfit.

ETA: ITA that any of the 3 would be great.

[katydid1971]

I'd come down from Portland to shop with you!!!!

Careful, I'll take you up on that offer ;) Maybe we could meet in Woodburn :thumbsup:

[PMJ]

2 or 3 . All cute though!

[katydid1971]

And the winner is...
http://www.zappos.com/nine-west-danee-red-patent-croc
Ok so I got yet another pair of shoes, all the other had something or other wrong with them (fit/style) that's why I wasn't sold on any of them. I ordered these and 2 other pairs from zappos and I like these the best :) Thanks for you input.

[SnuggleBuggles]

OOh!!! Super awesome!!

Beth