Exersaucers

[megs4413]

What do we think? We didn't have one with DD1, but DS loved his for a couple months. DD2 is almost ready for one and I can tell she would love it, but I'm reading that OTs and PTs hate them. What do you think? What did you do? Would you make the same choice now? TIA!

[StantonHyde]

um, that's how I survived that few months time period when it worked for them!!!! To heck with what PTs hate---and, believe me, I love my PT ;) but this is survival here, not optimum outcomes. At least it was with me....

[megs4413]

um, that's how I survived that few months time period when it worked for them!!!! To heck with what PTs hate---and, believe me, I love my PT ;) but this is survival here, not optimum outcomes. At least it was with me....

This is where I'm at with this, but I feel super guilty about it. It's not that bad right?

[AshleyAnn]

Anything is bad if over used or used wrong. DD had a jumparoo and an exersaucer and used both for a LONG time because she was a late walker. I could never have functioned without it

[Kindra178]

https://www.luriechildrens.org/en-us/care-services/specialties-services/physical-therapy/resources/Pages/motor-development-gear.aspx

I followed the above advice. I guess I am not sure why you need one?

[KpbS]

I used one with all 3 of mine but not for more than 20 min at a time. They all loved it and didn't have any developmental problems. It was great for grabbing a shower. I could see them and they were entertained and could see me.

[sariana]

I don't have an opinion on this topic; I just wanted to say it's good to see you, Megs!

[petesgirl]

I don't have an opinion on this topic; I just wanted to say it's good to see you, Megs!
O
Yes to this! :waving4:

[vtmom]

I wouldn't buy one and I didn't ask for one because of those guidelines but someone gave us one for DC 2 & 3 anyway. It was great!!! It gave me a place to put a baby for 20 minutes so I could shower, clean a toilet, etc. Like most things, if you use it sparingly I'm sure it will be fine. FWIW DC 2&3 walked sooner than DC1.

[flashy09]

In the real world, how many adults have you met with "an old Exersaucer injury?"

[JBaxter]

My oldest used a walker ( yup all the time) After DS2 was born they came out. I used them ALL THE TIME with all 3 boys We had a jumperoo too all 4 boys loved those. No hip deformities or issues walking at my house. They were ususally in the center of the living room or kitchen.

YES there were times each of them were in it more than 15 minutes. I even too it outside to do yard work

[nfowife]

My oldest DD was born with hip dysplasia and I wasn't told NOT to use an exersaucer. If you follow the guidelines for using- which is that their tiptoes should touch the ground- then it should be fine for short periods of time.

[Philly Mom]

Great to see you Megs. I just brought out our exersaucer. Both DD1 and 2 love it. Obviously my toddler should not be playing in it but she climbs in for a few mins of fun and then lets the baby have a turn. DD1 then plays with DD2 in it, pushing the buttons and making things move. It is fun to watch the two of them play together. I wouldn't leave a baby in all day, but I find it can give me a good chunk of time to do something without a baby on my hip.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[brittone2]

I've worked in early intervention as a physical therapist, and yes, most of my colleagues are not big fans. I think for a typically developing child, it is probably not a significant risk. However, for a preemie or a child showing delays or at risk of delay, I would definitely skip it. The issue is that the muscles don't fire with the same activity pattern that active standing encourages. This has been confirmed via EMG studies where researchers can use electrodes to look at which muscles are activated and in what patterns.
The recommendation is generally if you are going to use one to keep it to say 30 min per day. The issue with that is that it adds up quickly. 15 mins while you shower, 10 mins during a phone call, 15 mins while you prep dinner, 10 mins while you tend to your other child, etc. Human nature. That's one reason I opted not to have one; I just know it is too easy to overuse. The other issue is that we have so many devices to contain babies these days. Many are not just in the saucer, but also in other devices. Altogether, that time adds up and detracts from floor time, etc.
The other thing I've witnessed many times when walking into a home as a therapist, or into daycares, etc. is that all too often parents or caregivers are busy (understandably!) while the child is in the saucer, and they fail to remove a baby showing signs of fatigue. So I would walk in and see 4-6 month olds partly slumped over, etc. and no one was all that attentive.
YMMV. Most people use them and don't have issues, but I'd skip it entirely for kids at risk of delay or showing any delay as time goes on. I'd also be attentive to how quickly time in it adds up, especially combined with other devices. And be aware that standing it in is not the same as actively standing while holding onto a surface...different muscle recruitment patterns, etc. which does theoretically affect core strength, etc. negatively if overused.

[trales]

We used one with DD1, bought on Craigslist for $20, then sold months later for $20. It was the only way I could shower or used the toilet when she was that age. I liked it and she liked it. Granted she was only happy in for about 10 minutes, then time to move on. I say go for it.

[liz]

Loved our Exersaucer and Jumperoo and so did my kids. No issues here. We limited the amount of time too.

[georgiegirl]

That's where Ds2 goes when I have to do the dishes. I would have never showered without one when I had Ds1. I seriously had him in there until 18 months because it kept him contained. He was walking at 9.5 months, but he was short, so he wasn't able to climb out until 18 months...lol.

[Momit]

We received one from a friend and DS really enjoyed it. We had a swing, a bouncy seat, an Exersaucer, a pack n play and a play mat all stationed at various locations around the house. They were all great when we used them for 10-15 minutes at a time. I agree with PPs that the issue is probably when they are used for long periods of time and kids are not closely supervised.

[Ceepa]

We used the Exersaucer and loved it. It gave me a much needed break and DC would kick with joy at the sight of it.

We passed it on to a family having their first baby.

[scrooks]

Oh gosh...it's the only way I can get dinner prepped or dressed in the morning! All 3 of mine have been in the exersaucer (ds2 currently). The other 2 were both walking before 1. We didn't see any ill effects. I totally get the need to just contain them for a minute sometimes. I'm right there with you!!!

[AnnieW625]

We didn't have one, but they had them at DDs daycare. DD1 was never a huge fan of them, but I think DD2 used one more. I think I would have pushed getting one if we had more open space in our house. I have no issues with then what so ever.

[llama8]

I used an exersaucer and jumperoo for both of my DD's and I credit them for their early developing muscle tone. I used them from 2 months (holding up head on own) until 11 months when they were walking. I used them for only a little bit each day, but I found that my kids blossomed. I think they made them stronger by forcing them to use their muscles. They were sitting up at 5 months, pulling up on the crib at 6 months and fullystanding at 7 months, and walking unassisted at 10-11 months and running around that time too. I credit both the exersaucer and jumperoo for that. Again, I would limit how much time per day as many people overuse them, leading to physical issues. If you use them right, they are engaging developmental toys and I would feel no guilt over using them.

[maestramommy]

We never had one for DD1 and 2, and it was fine. Then we got one as a housewarming gift before DD3 was born. She LOVED it. Never saw anyone whap up and down the way she did. And FTR she has the strongest core of her sisters, as well as musculature in general. Her gross motor skills showed up before the other two as well.