Does anyone have both of these? Which do you prefer?

I'm looking for a carrier for mainly a small infant in the front facing-in carry. I'm pretty short & very busty, if that matters. One thing I hate in carriers in the excessive amount of fabric that I always seem to have. I don't want to have a great big bow at my waist. I'm also looking for something relatively easy to put on & take off. I had a Wilkinet with DS & while it was comfy, I dreaded putting it on because it was so cumbersome.

Do either of these seem to fit what I'm looking for? Any other suggestions?

Thanks!
Allison