Keyfit for us. I had a Snugride 22 for DS1 and was less than thrilled with it so I went with the Chicco for DS2. Loved how solid the Keyfit felt but really loved the install of the base. It was just really an easy seat to use.
I see lots of people mention problems with the sunshade. And I admit, it is small. BUT I could get mine to rotate forward by undoing a few small patches of velcro in the back. My seat is currently out on loan to a friend so I can't check it out, but I remember doing this several times with DS2. I don't think I'm imagining it......but I'm sure that's possible.
Mom to Two Wild and Crazy Boys and One Sweet Baby Girl