So DH and I have been going round and round over what to name DS2. DS1 was hard enough to figure out. He recently came up with the idea of letting me choose the first name - no restrictions - if he could pick the middle name - also no restrictions. The catch is that he won't tell me the middle name he wants before I agree to this plan.

So what would you do? Would you let your DH pick the middle name without you?

Should probably also add that DH only seems to like really old fashion names and I lean more toward more contemporary names. DH's suggestions so far have been Sheldon, Leonard, Russell, Manning, and Malcom.