Originally Posted by
HallsofVA
My favorites are the 7nt Caribbean cruises (Eastern or Western), since you get the full assortment of shows, activities, meals, and a mix of sea days and port days. They can actually be cheaper on a cost per night basis than the 3 or 4nt cruises are. The time also gives the kids time to bond more with the counsellors, which could increase the likelihood that the toddler will adjust to the nursery long enough for you to enjoy an adult brunch or activity if you need a break. Both have good beaches available, which are easy excursions to do with toddlers and preschoolers. The 4nt (or 5nt) Bahamas cruise is also a good choice, since you get at least 1 sea day. I think the 3nt is just too short, and there's a risk that you may not make it to Disney's private island if the weather is bad that day, which is a wonderful place for the kids, since there is no flexibility in that schedule.
With a preschooler and toddler, definitely take advantage of the off-peak times to go (assuming you can get out of work or other obligations) since it's much cheaper to go when everyone else is in school. We've sailed on a 7nt in early December for as low as $2600 for the 4 of us, and there are even cheaper times in sept/oct and jan/feb. We also did a 4nt kids sail free cruise in January, that was about 1500 for 4 of us, but you never know too far in advance if they're going to offer a deal like that. On the 4nt cruise, we had no interest in seeing Nassau, and the kids are too young to make Atlantis worth the cost, so we just stayed on the ship and enjoyed the pools that day, sort of like an additional sea day.
As far as the different ships, DCL has historically had 2 ships, Magic and Wonder, that were basically the same but one did Caribbean cruises and the other did Bahamas cruises. Their newest ship, the Dream, is arriving in Port Canaveral, FL tomorrow morning (around 6am) for the first time having just been built. It will take over the Bahamas cruises, and the Wonder will leave on Saturday for a relocation cruise through the Panama Canal to start doing Mexican Riviera cruises in the spring and fall, and will summer in Alaska. DCL is building another new ship, the Fantasy, which is identical to the Dream, and will do the Caribbean cruises starting in March 2012. But your choice of ship will still be based on where you want to go.
Summer cruises are expensive, especially this coming summer when DCL will only have one ship sailing out of Florida, unless you book on opening day or when they are first released. We booked the cheapest 5nt cruise for this summer, the 8/16/11 cruise on the new Disney Dream, the morning they were released in November 2009, and the cost was about $2800 for an oceanview room for 4 of us. I tried to rebook it while onboard 2 weeks later (you get additional discounts and onboard credit when you book another cruise while onboard) and it had sold out in all the lower categories already. That cruise has been sold out up to the concierge category for a few months now, and would now cost well over $6000 for us to book it. However, as the date for making payments approaches, people will drop out, and there may be some availability, but who knows how much.
Do you really need a balcony? We sailed 3 times in suites (by getting cheap upgrades at the port the morning of the cruise) and found that even when the kids were 2, we never used the balcony enough to really justify the added cost. So we generally book oceanview rooms these days, unless we get an awesome deal on a verandah, and save the money for pictures or excursions. The new ships will have "virtual portholes" in their inside rooms, that broadcast video of the outside into a porthole shaped LCD panel in the room to give the appearance of having a real porthole. So even the inside rooms will have more light than normal.
Keep your eye out for booking codes that you may be eligible for, especially if you are flexible for when you go. Are you a Florida resident? They often release discounted florida resident rates on Bahamas and Caribbean cruises to fill them. Anyone in your family or travelling group active or retired military or have ties to various military or defense organizations? The military discount rates, when offered, are incredible, and the eligible person can book up to 3 rooms for themselves and others. They've also released discounts for Canada and UK residents on various cruises, and have offered kids sail free or kids 50% off specials. Sometimes they just offer up their lowest category rooms for really cheap prices to fill the ships.
Disney doesn't let anyone discount their cruises, so there is no cheaper way to book a cruise, other than by having someone book one for you while onboard to get the 10% discount and additional onboard credit that is offered. Otherwise, the main comparison you'll find is comparing what onboard credits or other incentives the travel agent or agency is offering, that are generally higher than what DCL offers (and may be combinable.) I book through a travel agent to get the additional onboard credit that they offer, and to also have someone help with the details when I get bogged down at work. (though I do a lot of my own legwork because that's the way I am.)
DCL hasn't yet released it's plans for the rest of 2012, and we hope to hear more in the next few months or so.