Looking for a really quaint beach for a beach vacation. An
island would be even cooler! A bigger plus if we can drive
there from Cincinnati.

Not very busy, not crowded
Not touristy (NO Myrtle Beach)
Great local restaurants to walk to
Fun little shops to discover
Homemade candy stores to walk to
Homemade ice cream shop to walk to

In my head, this is how I picture Mackinac Island except maybe
Mackinac Island might get pretty busy.

Are there any other places to discover??