For younger DD (7) the hits were...
Purple plush throw from Target
Bean bag chair
Mermaid Barbie
Yippit
For older DD (12), the hits were....
plush blanket from Target
Yippit (seriously, who knew?)
Doctor Who necklace and pins from Hop Topic
The book Unbored which was a complete impulse purchase
The only real miss was the Flynn Rider "Barbie" for younger DD. She had asked Santa for a "boy Barbie" and Flynn was not at all what she had in mind. But she also can't really tell me what she would have preferred. Oh well.