We have used both Huggies Overnights and Huggies Pull-ups nighttime. They are equally absorbent IMO. And FWIW, I don't feel like pull-ups are any easier. They all have those velcro sides, and unless the velcro is laying just right, it's super easy for a corner of it to come out and be scratchy/uncomfortable. Especially when a kid is pulling them up and down. I wish they made them without velcro - then they'd be truly "pull-up".

So because of all of this, I'd just stick with the Huggies Overnights. Cheaper.

eta: will have to check out the Underjams or Goodnights if they don't have the velcro sides...I've not paid that much attention to them because they are SO expensive!!