Barefoot Dreams Cardigan Dupe at Costco?!

[Moneypenny]

I got my sweaters and have opened one. Somewhat on the fence, I need to try them on with different outfits. I feel they run somewhat small. I ordered a Medium and the arms are very tight. The length is a little shorter than pictured in the photo. They are definitely thinner than the name brand, although I'm guessing them will fluff up a little because they were very tightly folded up in the package. The material definitely feels very nice and the fabric does look similar. If large comes back in stock, I might try to exchange. I think this has great potential if the fit is good for you, and I definitely say to size up.

I ordered two in size S, black and blue. The black one is so tight in the arms I can barely get it on, so that's being returned. The blue is roomy and comfortable (although holy wrinkles, Batman!) so I'll keep that one. I think the sizing must just be very inconsistent.

[Twin Mom]

Shows all sizes back in stock now. I just ordered black and blue in a small. I have a tan BD circle cardigan already so I’ll see how they compare. I really don’t need another cardigan especially black but I couldn’t pass up that price.

[Melaine]

Shows all sizes back in stock now. I just ordered black and blue in a small. I have a tan BD circle cardigan already so I’ll see how they compare. I really don’t need another cardigan especially black but I couldn’t pass up that price.

Thanks for letting me know! I am grabbing them in large. I wish you didn't have to open them to check size, but they are packaged with a ribbon all folded up. Which looks cute, but I'm really wondering what will be best if the sizes are inconsistent. I know they return everything but I hate to mess them up!

[mikala]

They seem to be restocked in all sizes!

[athompson]

Thanks for posting! I ordered three mediums and you all are right, the sizing is all over the place.
Black medium fits my 4 ' 10"10-year old
Blue medium fits my 5 ' 2" 12-year-old
Beige medium fits my 5' 9" 14-year-old
So, the girls all have new sweaters and I am back to the drawing board:-)

[usermuser]

Thanks for posting! I ordered three mediums and you all are right, the sizing is all over the place.
Black medium fits my 4 ' 10"10-year old
Blue medium fits my 5 ' 2" 12-year-old
Beige medium fits my 5' 9" 14-year-old
So, the girls all have new sweaters and I am back to the drawing board:-)

Lol this is funny! All three girls got lucky! So what size are you getting for yourself and in what color?

Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk

[ett]

Thanks for posting! I ordered three mediums and you all are right, the sizing is all over the place.
Black medium fits my 4 ' 10"10-year old
Blue medium fits my 5 ' 2" 12-year-old
Beige medium fits my 5' 9" 14-year-old
So, the girls all have new sweaters and I am back to the drawing board:-)

Haha! So funny! DH always hounds on me for returning too much stuff but how can one not when there's so much sizing inconsistency?

[Melaine]

And now it's completely out of stock!

[mommybug]

I just saw these at the Seattle 4th Ave store if someone in in the area is looking for them.

[3isEnough]

Thanks for posting! I ordered three mediums and you all are right, the sizing is all over the place.
Black medium fits my 4 ' 10"10-year old
Blue medium fits my 5 ' 2" 12-year-old
Beige medium fits my 5' 9" 14-year-old
So, the girls all have new sweaters and I am back to the drawing board:-)

I read this yesterday and was concerned since I had a black small on the way. However, I tried it on last night and it fits perfectly! For reference, I'm 5'3" and 112lbs. I love the sweater and am so happy everyone posted about it since I never would have stumbled upon it myself.