I have a pair of Keen Newport H2 that are super comfy, but also not very cute and make my feet look like boats when wearing shorts. Last summer I tried the Rose style from Amazon. I normally wear a size 7, but my Newports are 7.5, so that is what I ordered but they seemed too short/tight on my toes. I read that some of the colors ran differently in sizes, so I returned the original pair and ordered a different color in a 7.5, same problem. I then went to a local store (which told me that Keen does not sell 1/2 sizes, ha!). I tried the 7, too short, but the 8 was too loose. So I'm guessing that the Rose just does not suit my foot? Can anyone compare the sizing/fit of the Bali Strap to the Rose? Thinking of trying those out, as I would love a cuter option to wear with my Skorts and shorts to Disney at the end of March, as well as other amusement parks this summer. Should I try my normal size or size up?