I'm really only a sporadic user of moisturizer, and usually depend on samples I get in beauty sample boxes, so YMMV, but I just found a night cream that I would actually buy in full-size form: Olay Regenerist Retinol 24. It has no scent at all and feels amazing going on, immediately sinks into my skin, and I swear that my skin looks better after only two days.
I feel like I have tried all the creams, and very rarely have I found one that I've liked enough even to finish the sample, so the fact that I'm actually looking forward to using this again tonight speaks volumes.
DC1 -- 2005 DD -- 2009 DS -- 2011