I also have hazel eyes and fair skin with pink undertones, although my hair is currently undyed, dark brown with red/auburn undertones, and some natural blonde highlights.
What I've been looking for as far as eye makeup is a matte aubergine or plum liner (or a shadow that I can apply with a chisel brush) to play up the green tones in my eyes. I typically keep my daytime eye makeup neutral - I have one of the Urban Decay NAKED mini palette. My all-over lid color from lash to crease is a warm beige, then I apply a taupe-y tan to the crease & outer corner, and use a kind of ecru color as a brow & inner corner highlight.
As for nighttime glam ... I haven't outgrown the smokey eye, which I use browns & taupes for, sometimes with a little shimmer.
I'm currently looking at ColourPop's
"What a Hoot" palette, inspired by Animal Crossing, but I'm also intrigued by
"Nook, Inc."
My eyes are deep set, so I struggle to wear blues, violets, or pinks without looking bruised or consumptive. (If there's a way to apply them without that effect, I haven't learned it yet!)
I've been using Benefit's
"They're Real!" mascara for almost a decade; I'm looking to try their
"Roller Lash" curling formula sometime soon.
I haven't tried anything flashy and I'm looking to replace most of my makeup and brushes soonish anyway, so I'll probably keep this thread in mind when I'm shopping.