Trash. We recently found the stash and no one was interested. Shiver indeed, lol
FYI, when DS3 was little, he combined everyone's baby teeth together, unbeknownst to anyone. So forget finding DS1 first lost tooth etc. When we found that stash, there was dozens of baby teeth all mixed together. It was unsettling to say the least . Unanimously, the vote from the kids was to trash them immediately.