I bought this also a around a year ago, for all the reasons mentioned. We had the toaster oven for years and loved it, so it was a great way to jump on the air fryer trend without getting a standalone air fryer with lower capacity. It is exactly the same size but has the additional functionality. I hated cleaning the tray too but then I discovered parchment sheets and they have been a game changer:
https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B09PY...b_b_asin_title.
They have holes so the air can still flow around but they minimize the mess, especially with wet sticky things like chicken wings.