I've been using a combo of things - the moby gets very warm and is a pain to get on and off but is very supportive for a newborn. However, I've had as much luck with a stretchy one-shoulder pouch like the KKAFP (can find them used.) we use this as our go-to carrier. I also use a linen Sakura which is supportive but seems to be less comfy for dS.
One other caveat with wraps is you can't lift both arms instead of just one arm. I stopped using the moby at home when I realized I couldn't get into my upper cabinets with it.
If you want a two shoulder option that is more poppable, beco Gemini might be an option.
shannon
~~~~~~~~~~~
Another Queen of the House of Boys:
DS#1 2003
DS#2 my mother's day gift 2012
DH
Mikey, the cat and rhinestone-collared, pink-leashed Schatze, our Rottweiler girl